I was very happy when the NCAA dumped the BCS and went to a playoff to decide the national champion. However, four teams are not enough. What I don't like is a team like Middle Tennessee State could have the quality of a SEC team one year, go undefeated, and not have a chance at the national championship, even if it is the best team that particular year, because it plays in a weak conference. If I was king of sports, the college football national championship would be a 12-team playoff. The ten conference champions would qualify plus two wildcards. The bowl system would be used like NIT is in basketball, as a reward for teams with a good season, but who did not qualify for the main tournament. For those who say 12 teams is too many, every other division in the NCAA or NAIA uses at least a 16-team playoff, including Division III that has a 32-team playoff.
In my vision, a committee would seed the teams from 1-16. The top 4 would be granted a bye in the first round. A wildcard would not be allowed to have a top-4 seed, unless it has a top 4 record, regardless of the strength of the other conferences.
This would be my bracket after week 6. Unless a head-to-head matchup has actually occured, I used point differential to break a tie. At this point, it is just a model. Things will happen the way they are supposed to be at the end of the season. (Update 11/5 Now that the college football playoff rankings are now out, if two teams are tied and have not had the opportunity to play each other, yet, the higher ranked team will be considered "the conference leader". Also, the record for Toledo is reflected before the week began, which is when I would have updated the project if I had time).
*=Wildcard
(1) Clemson (8-0 ACC, 13-0) would have a bye
(9) Western Kentucky (8-0 CUSA, 11-2) @ (8) Houston (7-1 AAC, 12-1)
(12) Arkansas St. (8-0 SBC, 10-3) @ (5) Iowa (8-0 Big 10, 12-1)*
(4) Oklahoma (8-1 Big 12, 11-1) would have a bye
(11) Bowling Green (7-1 MAC, 10-3) @ (6) Stanford (8-1 PAC-12, 11-2)
(3) Michigan St. (7-1 BIg 10, 12-1) would have a bye
(10) San Diego St. (8-0 MWC, 10-3) @ (7) Ohio St. (7-1 Big 10, 11-1)*
(2) Alabama (7-1 SEC, 12-1) would have a bye)
First two teams out: Notre Dame (10-2), Florida St. (10-2)
Sunday, October 4, 2015
Week 5 High School Football playoffs
I wanted to see what the playoff field would look like if the regular season ended today. There is one change in the way teams qualify for the playoffs. Seven leagues will receive an extra automatic bid due to the playoff success (DL, PVL, SFL, SL, TVL, TCC, and VOL). That means the number of at-large bids drops from 28 to 21 (at this point, all but one team in the leagues with the extra bids would have made the playoffs anyway. Pioneer is the team that wouldn't have, and Gregori would now be out.) There are two changes in division placement. League champions now have to play in the division the league is assigned. For example, Wood is small enough for Division III, but since it is leading a Division I league, it would have to play in Division I. The second one is that the definition of "competition success" has broadened. The only team that would have moved up because of the playoffs would not be in as of now (but expect that to change at the actual end of season).
Last 4 teams in: Vintage, Highlands, St. Mary's, Franklin (Elk Grove)
First 2 teams out: Gregori, Golden Valley (I would have done 1st 4 if I thought about it earlier, but I remember these are the first two.)
Division I
(16) Enochs (Modesto) @ (1) Folsom
(9) Woodcreek (Roseville) @ (8) Pleasant Grove (Elk Grove)
(12) Modesto @ (5) Cosumnes Oaks (Elk Grove)
(13) West (Tracy) @ (4) Oak Ridge (El Dorado Hills)
(11) Monterey Trail (Elk Grove) @ (6) Turlock
(14) Chavez (Stockton) @ (3) Wood (Vacaville)
(10) McNair (Stockton) @ (7) Franklin (Elk Grove)
(15) Kennedy (Sacramento) @ (2) Elk Grove
DIVISION II
(16) Tokay (Lodi) @ (1) Grant (Sacramento)
(9) Whitney (Rocklin) @ (8) Turlock
(12) Downey (Modesto) @ (5) Antelope
(13) Sacramento @ (4) Napa
(11) Jesuit (Carmichael) @ (6) Rocklin
(14) Vanden (Fairfield) @ (3) Del Oro (Loomis)
(10) Del Campo (Fair Oaks) @ (7) St. Mary's (Stockton)
(15) Vintage (Napa) @ (2) Granite Bay
DIVISION III
(16) Pioneer (Woodland) @ (1) Oakdale
(9) Vista del Lago (Folsom) @ (8) Los Banos
(12) Sierra (Manteca) @ (5) River Valley (Yuba City)
(13) Christian Brothers (Sacramento) @ (4) Patterson
(11) Burbank (Sacramento) @ (6) Placer (Auburn)
(14) Central Valley (Ceres) @ (3) Manteca
(10) Benicia @ (7) Inderkum (Sacramento)
(15) El Dorado (Placrrville) @ (2) Central Catholic (Modesto)
DIVISION IV
(8) Lindhurst (Olivehurst) @ (1) Sonora
(5) Weston Ranch (Stockton) @ (4) Union Mine (El Dorado)
(6) Dixon @ (3) Calaveras (San Andreas)
(7) Center (Antelope) @ (2) Lathrop
DIVISION V
(8) Amador (Sutter Creek) @ (1) Bear River (Grass Valley)
(5) Orestimba (Newman) @ (4) Escalon
(6) Marysville @ (3) Hughson
(7) Hilmar @ (2) Highlands (North Highlands)
DIVISION VI
(8) Rio Vista @ (1) Capital Christian
(5) Summerville (Tuolumne City) @ (4) Ripon Christian
(6) Golden Sierra (Garden Valley) @ (3) Gustine
(7) Mariposa @ (2) Bradshaw Christian (Sacramento)
DIVISION VII
CCAA 1 Stone Ridge Christian would have a bye
SMAL 3 Valley Christian (Roseville) @ CCAA 2 Brookside Christian (Stockton)
SMAL 1 Woodland Christian would have a bye
CCAA 3 Big Valley (Modesto) @ SMAL 2 Delta (Clarksburg)
Three teams I think will be in the playoffs who are not there now: Colfax, Gregori (Modesto), Modesto Christian
Three teams 1 think won't be in the playoffs who would be there now: Monterey Trail (Elk Grove), West (Tracy), Weston Ranch (Stockton)
DIVISION III
(16) Pioneer (Woodland) @ (1) Oakdale
(9) Vista del Lago (Folsom) @ (8) Los Banos
(12) Sierra (Manteca) @ (5) River Valley (Yuba City)
(13) Christian Brothers (Sacramento) @ (4) Patterson
(11) Burbank (Sacramento) @ (6) Placer (Auburn)
(14) Central Valley (Ceres) @ (3) Manteca
(10) Benicia @ (7) Inderkum (Sacramento)
(15) El Dorado (Placrrville) @ (2) Central Catholic (Modesto)
DIVISION IV
(8) Lindhurst (Olivehurst) @ (1) Sonora
(5) Weston Ranch (Stockton) @ (4) Union Mine (El Dorado)
(6) Dixon @ (3) Calaveras (San Andreas)
(7) Center (Antelope) @ (2) Lathrop
DIVISION V
(8) Amador (Sutter Creek) @ (1) Bear River (Grass Valley)
(5) Orestimba (Newman) @ (4) Escalon
(6) Marysville @ (3) Hughson
(7) Hilmar @ (2) Highlands (North Highlands)
DIVISION VI
(8) Rio Vista @ (1) Capital Christian
(5) Summerville (Tuolumne City) @ (4) Ripon Christian
(6) Golden Sierra (Garden Valley) @ (3) Gustine
(7) Mariposa @ (2) Bradshaw Christian (Sacramento)
DIVISION VII
CCAA 1 Stone Ridge Christian would have a bye
SMAL 3 Valley Christian (Roseville) @ CCAA 2 Brookside Christian (Stockton)
SMAL 1 Woodland Christian would have a bye
CCAA 3 Big Valley (Modesto) @ SMAL 2 Delta (Clarksburg)
Three teams I think will be in the playoffs who are not there now: Colfax, Gregori (Modesto), Modesto Christian
Three teams 1 think won't be in the playoffs who would be there now: Monterey Trail (Elk Grove), West (Tracy), Weston Ranch (Stockton)
Friday, September 11, 2015
2015 NCAA Division I-A top 4/Lower Division Playoffs
NCAA DIVISION I FBS (4 in playoffs)
Team and week 13 opponent
1. Clemson (vs. North Carolina @ Charlotte, NC)
2. Alabama (@ Auburn)
3. Oklahoma (@ #11 Oklahoma St.)
4. Iowa (@ Nebraska 11/27)
NCAA DIVISION I FCS
Round 2 playoffs
Chattanooga @ #1 Jacksonville St.
NCAA DIVISION II Second Round
Super Regional 1
(5) Indiana (PA) @ (1) Shepherd
(3) Assumption @ (2) Slippery Rock
Super Regional 4
(4) Colorado St.-Pueblo @ (1) Midwestern St.
(6) Grand Valley St. @ (2) Ferris St.
Super Regional 3
(4) Valdosta St. @ (1) West Georgia
(6) Tuskegee @ (2) North Alabama
Super Regional 2
(4) Humboldt St. @ (1) Northwest Missouri St.
(7) Emporia St. @ (3) Henderson St.
NCAA DIVISION III Second Round
St. John's (MN) @ St. Thomas
Wabash @ Thomas More
SUNY-Cortland @ Linfield
Mary Hardin-Baylor @ Huntingdon
Albright @ Mt. Union
Johns Hopkins @ Wesley
Ohio Northern @ Wisconsin-Oshkosh
Wheaton (IL) @ Wisconsin-Whitewater
NAIA Quarterfinals
Tabor @ Morningside
Southern Oregon @ Baker
Marian @ Grand View
Montana Tech @ St. Francis (IN)
NCAA DIVISION II Second Round
Super Regional 1
(5) Indiana (PA) @ (1) Shepherd
(3) Assumption @ (2) Slippery Rock
Super Regional 4
(4) Colorado St.-Pueblo @ (1) Midwestern St.
(6) Grand Valley St. @ (2) Ferris St.
Super Regional 3
(4) Valdosta St. @ (1) West Georgia
(6) Tuskegee @ (2) North Alabama
Super Regional 2
(4) Humboldt St. @ (1) Northwest Missouri St.
(7) Emporia St. @ (3) Henderson St.
NCAA DIVISION III Second Round
St. John's (MN) @ St. Thomas
Wabash @ Thomas More
SUNY-Cortland @ Linfield
Mary Hardin-Baylor @ Huntingdon
Albright @ Mt. Union
Johns Hopkins @ Wesley
Ohio Northern @ Wisconsin-Oshkosh
Wheaton (IL) @ Wisconsin-Whitewater
NAIA Quarterfinals
Tabor @ Morningside
Southern Oregon @ Baker
Marian @ Grand View
Montana Tech @ St. Francis (IN)
Tuesday, May 26, 2015
Year 3 of baseball/softball NIT if I Was King of Sports
by Matt Groom
This is the third year of my baseball NIT bracket. If I was King of Sports, there would be a NIT for NCAA baseball. The idea started two years ago when 30-29 Florida was invited to play in the NCAA baseball tournament and 43-10 Campbell was not. Maybe Campbell was not one of the best 64 teams, but I do believe that 43-10 deserves some extra baseball. I created a bracket that would invite all teams that had a better record than the at-large with the worst record in the tournament. I would also invite Division II teams that did not make it to its College World Series if there were not enough teams to fill in the bracket. In this tournament, the only teams invited would be those who had a better record than the worst at-large team, no more, no less. The NCAA tournament is meant to invite the best teams. My tournament's purpose is to reward the teams with great seasons who did not get an NCAA tournament invite. Because of that, the teams invited, hosts, and seeds are decided solely by record. If two teams tie, then strength of schedule would break the tie.
In case you are interested, here is the link to the actual NCAA tournament bracket:
http://www.ncaa.com/interactive-bracket/baseball/d1
Here would be the field for the 2015 season if I Was King of Sports
Team in question: Mississippi Rebels (30-26 .536). This year, 61 schools had better records. Two have had an equal record. If this tournament happened my way, there would be 64 teams in it (the 63 plus one division II school). The playing style would be the same as the NCAA tournament.
Region I- @ Jacksonville, FL (Host: North Florida Ospreys) (Division II school in italics)
(4) Nova Southeastern (39-13) vs. (1) North Florida (45-16)
(3) McNeese St. (32-25) vs. (2) Duke (31-22)
Region XVI- @ St. Louis, MO (Host: St. Louis Bilikins)
(4) Rider (28-22) vs. (1) St. Louis (35-21)
(3) Illinois-Chicago (29-22) vs. (2) Southeast Missouri St. (36-23)
Region VIII- @ Annapolis, MD (Host: Navy Midshipmen)
(4) Wagner (29-23) vs. (1) Navy (37-20)
(3) Connecticut (35-25) vs. (2) George Washington (32-22)
Region IX- @ Thibodaux, LA (Host: Nicholls St. Colonels)
(4) Troy (30-25) vs. (1) Nicholls St. (34-19)
(3) UAB (33-25) vs. (2) Arkansas-Pine Bluff (25-16)
Region V- @ Hattiesburg, MS (Host: Southern Mississippi Golden Eagles)
(4) New Mexico (32-27) vs. (1) Southern Mississippi (36-18)
(3) Northwestern St. (31-23) vs. (2) UC-Irvine (33-23)
Region XII- @ Columbus, OH (Host: Ohio St. Buckeyes)
(4) Evansville (29-24) vs. (1) Ohio St. (35-20)
(3) Texas Tech (31-24) vs. (2) Central Michigan (35-22)
Region IV- @ Rock Hill, SC (Host: Winthrop Eagles)
(4) Bryant (29-25) vs. (1) Winthrop (40-19)
(3) South Carolina (32-25) @ (2) North Carolina (34-24)
Region XIII- @ Baltimore, MD (Host: Maryland-Baltimore County Retrievers)
(4) Sacramento St. (32-27) vs. (1) Maryland-Baltimore County (34-20)
(3) Campbell (32-25) vs. (2) Penn (22-15)
Region VI- @ Milwaukee, WI (Host: Milwaukee Panthers)
(4) Washington (29-25) vs. (1) Milwaukee (39-20)
(3) Kent St. (31-22) vs. (2) Michigan St. (34-23)
Region XI- @ Memphis, TN (Host: Memphis Tigers)
(4) Central Arkansas (29-24) vs. (1) Memphis (37-21)
(3) Ball St. (33-25) vs. (2) San Diego (33-22)
Region III- @ Hammond, LA (Host: Southeastern Louisiana Lions)
(4) Florida Gulf Coast (30-26) vs. (1) Southeast Louisiana (42-17)
(3) UTSA (33-25) vs. (2) Grand Canyon (32-22)
Region XIV- @ Norfolk, VA (Host: Norfolk St. Spartans)
(4) Samford (32-26) vs. (1) Norfolk St. (27-16)
(3) Davidson (28-22) vs. (2) Liberty (33-23)
Region VII- @ Mobile, AL (Host: South Alabama Jaguars)
(4) Middle Tennessee St. (32-27) vs. (1) South Alabama (37-20)
(3) Georgia Tech (32-23) vs. (2) Alabama St. (31-19)
Region X- @ Spartanburg, SC (Host: Wofford Terriers)
(4) Kentucky (30-25) vs. (1) Wofford (39-22)
(3) Jackson St. (32-25) vs. (2) South Dakota St. (33-23)
Region XV- @ Omaha, NE (Host: Creighton Blue Jays)
(4) Oklahoma (34-27) vs. (1) Creighton (32-19)
(3) Northridge St. (33-24) vs. (2) Nebraska (34-23)
Region II- @ Reno, NV (Host: Nevada Wolfpack)
(4) UC-Davis (30-26) vs. (1) Nevada (41-15)
(3) Arizona (31-24) vs. (2) Loyola Marymount (33-21)
I understand that if this tournament were to actually happen, there would have to be a set number of teams invited so that people behind the scenes can plan to
make it the best tournament possible for players, coaches, and fans. The way I have designed it does not call for that. It only calls for those who have great seasons.
This year, I have also designed one for softball. The same rules apply. This year, I allowed for a play-in game since there were a few extra teams. Fifty-one teams had better records than the worst at-large team to be invited to the NCAA tournament. This year, if this tournament was real, and I had everything my way, there would be 8 brackets with 6 teams each (plus 3 play-in games). The winners would advance to the championship series. Like the tournament, it would be double-elimination (except for the play-in games).
Team invited to NCAA tournament with the worst record: Kentucky (29-24, .547)
Region I- Kent, OH (Kent St.)
(6) Purdue (31-25)/Florida International (30-24) winner vs. (1) Kent St. (41-13)
(5) Canisius (26-19) vs. (2) IUPUI (33-18)
(4) Drake (32-21) vs. (3) Kennesaw St. (32-19)
Region VIII- Natchitoches, LA (Northwestern St.)
(6) Delaware (30-23) vs. (1) Northwestern St. (36-18)
(5) Hawai'i (32-22) vs. (2) Idaho St. (34-18)
(4) Louisiana Tech (31-19) vs. (3) Mercer (37-22)
Region IV- Riverside, CA (UC-Riverside)
(6) St. Joseph's (23-18) vs. (1) UC-Riverside (39-17)
(5) Ohio St. (30-22) vs. (2) San Jose St. (37-19)
(4) Texas St. (32-21) vs. (3) St. Francis (PA) (31-19)
Region V- Jacksonville, AL (Jacksonville St.)
(6) Savannah St. (22-17) vs. (1) Jacksonville St. (38-17)
(5) Elon (31-22) vs. (2) South Florida (36-20)
(4) Samford (32-22) vs. (3) Georgia St. (38-22)
Region III- Huntington, WV (Marshall)
(6) Lipscomb (31-25)/Grand Canyon (28-22) winner vs. (1) Marshall (35-15)
(5) Coastal Carolina (31-24) vs. (2) Harvard (28-15-1)
(4) Towson (31-22) vs. (3) Bucknell (35-20)
Region VI- Murray, KY (Murray St.)
(6) Miami (OH) (32-24) vs. (1) Murray St. (38-19)
(5) Troy (32-23) vs. (2) St. Louis (36-18)
(4) Stetson (30-20) vs. (3) Albany (30-18)
Region II- Dayton, OH (Dayton)
(6) Furman (31-25)/San Diego (29-23) winner vs. (1) Dayton (39-14)
(5) Rutgers (29-20) vs. (2) Stony Brook (30-16)
(4) Wichita St. (34-23) vs. (3) UAB (32-19)
Region VII- San Antonio, TX (UTSA)
(6) Manhattan (26-20) vs. (1) UTSA (36-18)
(5) Louisiana-Monroe (30-22) vs. (2) Tulsa (36-18)
(4) Fullerton St. (34-22) vs. (3) McNeese St. (36-20)
This is the third year of my baseball NIT bracket. If I was King of Sports, there would be a NIT for NCAA baseball. The idea started two years ago when 30-29 Florida was invited to play in the NCAA baseball tournament and 43-10 Campbell was not. Maybe Campbell was not one of the best 64 teams, but I do believe that 43-10 deserves some extra baseball. I created a bracket that would invite all teams that had a better record than the at-large with the worst record in the tournament. I would also invite Division II teams that did not make it to its College World Series if there were not enough teams to fill in the bracket. In this tournament, the only teams invited would be those who had a better record than the worst at-large team, no more, no less. The NCAA tournament is meant to invite the best teams. My tournament's purpose is to reward the teams with great seasons who did not get an NCAA tournament invite. Because of that, the teams invited, hosts, and seeds are decided solely by record. If two teams tie, then strength of schedule would break the tie.
In case you are interested, here is the link to the actual NCAA tournament bracket:
http://www.ncaa.com/interactive-bracket/baseball/d1
Here would be the field for the 2015 season if I Was King of Sports
Team in question: Mississippi Rebels (30-26 .536). This year, 61 schools had better records. Two have had an equal record. If this tournament happened my way, there would be 64 teams in it (the 63 plus one division II school). The playing style would be the same as the NCAA tournament.
Region I- @ Jacksonville, FL (Host: North Florida Ospreys) (Division II school in italics)
(4) Nova Southeastern (39-13) vs. (1) North Florida (45-16)
(3) McNeese St. (32-25) vs. (2) Duke (31-22)
Region XVI- @ St. Louis, MO (Host: St. Louis Bilikins)
(4) Rider (28-22) vs. (1) St. Louis (35-21)
(3) Illinois-Chicago (29-22) vs. (2) Southeast Missouri St. (36-23)
Region VIII- @ Annapolis, MD (Host: Navy Midshipmen)
(4) Wagner (29-23) vs. (1) Navy (37-20)
(3) Connecticut (35-25) vs. (2) George Washington (32-22)
Region IX- @ Thibodaux, LA (Host: Nicholls St. Colonels)
(4) Troy (30-25) vs. (1) Nicholls St. (34-19)
(3) UAB (33-25) vs. (2) Arkansas-Pine Bluff (25-16)
Region V- @ Hattiesburg, MS (Host: Southern Mississippi Golden Eagles)
(4) New Mexico (32-27) vs. (1) Southern Mississippi (36-18)
(3) Northwestern St. (31-23) vs. (2) UC-Irvine (33-23)
Region XII- @ Columbus, OH (Host: Ohio St. Buckeyes)
(4) Evansville (29-24) vs. (1) Ohio St. (35-20)
(3) Texas Tech (31-24) vs. (2) Central Michigan (35-22)
Region IV- @ Rock Hill, SC (Host: Winthrop Eagles)
(4) Bryant (29-25) vs. (1) Winthrop (40-19)
(3) South Carolina (32-25) @ (2) North Carolina (34-24)
Region XIII- @ Baltimore, MD (Host: Maryland-Baltimore County Retrievers)
(4) Sacramento St. (32-27) vs. (1) Maryland-Baltimore County (34-20)
(3) Campbell (32-25) vs. (2) Penn (22-15)
Region VI- @ Milwaukee, WI (Host: Milwaukee Panthers)
(4) Washington (29-25) vs. (1) Milwaukee (39-20)
(3) Kent St. (31-22) vs. (2) Michigan St. (34-23)
Region XI- @ Memphis, TN (Host: Memphis Tigers)
(4) Central Arkansas (29-24) vs. (1) Memphis (37-21)
(3) Ball St. (33-25) vs. (2) San Diego (33-22)
Region III- @ Hammond, LA (Host: Southeastern Louisiana Lions)
(4) Florida Gulf Coast (30-26) vs. (1) Southeast Louisiana (42-17)
(3) UTSA (33-25) vs. (2) Grand Canyon (32-22)
Region XIV- @ Norfolk, VA (Host: Norfolk St. Spartans)
(4) Samford (32-26) vs. (1) Norfolk St. (27-16)
(3) Davidson (28-22) vs. (2) Liberty (33-23)
Region VII- @ Mobile, AL (Host: South Alabama Jaguars)
(4) Middle Tennessee St. (32-27) vs. (1) South Alabama (37-20)
(3) Georgia Tech (32-23) vs. (2) Alabama St. (31-19)
Region X- @ Spartanburg, SC (Host: Wofford Terriers)
(4) Kentucky (30-25) vs. (1) Wofford (39-22)
(3) Jackson St. (32-25) vs. (2) South Dakota St. (33-23)
Region XV- @ Omaha, NE (Host: Creighton Blue Jays)
(4) Oklahoma (34-27) vs. (1) Creighton (32-19)
(3) Northridge St. (33-24) vs. (2) Nebraska (34-23)
Region II- @ Reno, NV (Host: Nevada Wolfpack)
(4) UC-Davis (30-26) vs. (1) Nevada (41-15)
(3) Arizona (31-24) vs. (2) Loyola Marymount (33-21)
I understand that if this tournament were to actually happen, there would have to be a set number of teams invited so that people behind the scenes can plan to
make it the best tournament possible for players, coaches, and fans. The way I have designed it does not call for that. It only calls for those who have great seasons.
This year, I have also designed one for softball. The same rules apply. This year, I allowed for a play-in game since there were a few extra teams. Fifty-one teams had better records than the worst at-large team to be invited to the NCAA tournament. This year, if this tournament was real, and I had everything my way, there would be 8 brackets with 6 teams each (plus 3 play-in games). The winners would advance to the championship series. Like the tournament, it would be double-elimination (except for the play-in games).
Team invited to NCAA tournament with the worst record: Kentucky (29-24, .547)
Region I- Kent, OH (Kent St.)
(6) Purdue (31-25)/Florida International (30-24) winner vs. (1) Kent St. (41-13)
(5) Canisius (26-19) vs. (2) IUPUI (33-18)
(4) Drake (32-21) vs. (3) Kennesaw St. (32-19)
Region VIII- Natchitoches, LA (Northwestern St.)
(6) Delaware (30-23) vs. (1) Northwestern St. (36-18)
(5) Hawai'i (32-22) vs. (2) Idaho St. (34-18)
(4) Louisiana Tech (31-19) vs. (3) Mercer (37-22)
Region IV- Riverside, CA (UC-Riverside)
(6) St. Joseph's (23-18) vs. (1) UC-Riverside (39-17)
(5) Ohio St. (30-22) vs. (2) San Jose St. (37-19)
(4) Texas St. (32-21) vs. (3) St. Francis (PA) (31-19)
Region V- Jacksonville, AL (Jacksonville St.)
(6) Savannah St. (22-17) vs. (1) Jacksonville St. (38-17)
(5) Elon (31-22) vs. (2) South Florida (36-20)
(4) Samford (32-22) vs. (3) Georgia St. (38-22)
Region III- Huntington, WV (Marshall)
(6) Lipscomb (31-25)/Grand Canyon (28-22) winner vs. (1) Marshall (35-15)
(5) Coastal Carolina (31-24) vs. (2) Harvard (28-15-1)
(4) Towson (31-22) vs. (3) Bucknell (35-20)
Region VI- Murray, KY (Murray St.)
(6) Miami (OH) (32-24) vs. (1) Murray St. (38-19)
(5) Troy (32-23) vs. (2) St. Louis (36-18)
(4) Stetson (30-20) vs. (3) Albany (30-18)
Region II- Dayton, OH (Dayton)
(6) Furman (31-25)/San Diego (29-23) winner vs. (1) Dayton (39-14)
(5) Rutgers (29-20) vs. (2) Stony Brook (30-16)
(4) Wichita St. (34-23) vs. (3) UAB (32-19)
Region VII- San Antonio, TX (UTSA)
(6) Manhattan (26-20) vs. (1) UTSA (36-18)
(5) Louisiana-Monroe (30-22) vs. (2) Tulsa (36-18)
(4) Fullerton St. (34-22) vs. (3) McNeese St. (36-20)
Monday, April 27, 2015
If I Was King of Sports: Rules NFL should adopt from other football leagues
There are some NFL football rules I would like changed, but I am not going to focus on those, including the "Calvin Johnson rule" about the "complete process of a catch". I will say it was a stupid rule when it happened to Calvin Johnson, and it was stupid when it happened to Dez Bryant of the Dallas Cowboys. This blog will focus on the rules that are in place in other football leagues, that I think should be in place in the NFL. By the way, adapting rules from other leagues would not be unprecedented. The NBA adopted the 3-point line when it merged with the ABA in 1976. Before that, the NBA did not have a 3-point line, but the ABA did to generate more offense.
Rule 1: Pass interference calls can be challenged by the coach. Where it is found: CFL
In the Canadian Football League (CFL), coaches are allowed to use one of their challenges on a pass interference call. The NFL needs to do the same. There are times the flow of games can be changed on a bad pass interference call. Plus, a 15-yard penalty can make a big impact on the game. There needs to be some accountability.
Rule 2: Have a player from each team run for the ball to determine who starts the game with the ball. Where it was found: XFL
As ridiculous as the XFL was in the one year of its existence, this rule was one of the few things it got right. It pitted two people in a contest to see who wants the ball more. It is more entertaining than just tossing a coin. These days, there is more of a focus towards safety issues, so there would have to be adjustments. Maybe the two athletes can run side-by-side, or run at a diangel. Whatever they decide, I want to see something more than a coin toss.
Rule 3: Make field goals and extra points harder. Where it is found: Arena football
"Goalposts" in the Arena Football League are 15 feet high and 9 and a half feet wide (as opposed to 10 feet high and 18 feet wide in the NFL). Field goals and extra points are not automatic in the AFL, because of the height and narrowness of the goalposts. The NFL experimented with having 14-foot wide goalposts at the Pro Bowl. The percentage of the field goals made was reduced from kickers who are normally "automatic".
Rule 4: Review helmet-to-helmet calls. Where it is found: NCAA
Like pass interference, the helmet-to-helmet calls can impact a game if they are mistakenly called. I understand that in live action, it can be difficult for officials to tell whether or not a player hit another one with his helmet or not. The referees are to rule on the side of safety in this case. There was a dispute on whether (I think it was) Ahmed Brooks of the San Francisco 49ers hit Seattle Seahawks quarterback, Russell Wilson, with his helmet. The referees called the penalty, and it cost the 49ers 15 yards, and Seattle eventually scored on that drive. Later in the week, the NFL reviewed it, and ruled that it should not have been a penalty on the 49ers. If I was King of Sports, those plays would be automatically reviewed like it is in the NCAA. Of course, the reason why it is reviewed in the NCAA is because those plays are grounds for ejection if the player was considered to be "targeting", and no one wants to see a player ejected for making a hard, legal hit. Those plays should be reviewed, because they can impact a game for one team if the call was ruled to be incorrect.
Rule 1: Pass interference calls can be challenged by the coach. Where it is found: CFL
In the Canadian Football League (CFL), coaches are allowed to use one of their challenges on a pass interference call. The NFL needs to do the same. There are times the flow of games can be changed on a bad pass interference call. Plus, a 15-yard penalty can make a big impact on the game. There needs to be some accountability.
Rule 2: Have a player from each team run for the ball to determine who starts the game with the ball. Where it was found: XFL
As ridiculous as the XFL was in the one year of its existence, this rule was one of the few things it got right. It pitted two people in a contest to see who wants the ball more. It is more entertaining than just tossing a coin. These days, there is more of a focus towards safety issues, so there would have to be adjustments. Maybe the two athletes can run side-by-side, or run at a diangel. Whatever they decide, I want to see something more than a coin toss.
Rule 3: Make field goals and extra points harder. Where it is found: Arena football
"Goalposts" in the Arena Football League are 15 feet high and 9 and a half feet wide (as opposed to 10 feet high and 18 feet wide in the NFL). Field goals and extra points are not automatic in the AFL, because of the height and narrowness of the goalposts. The NFL experimented with having 14-foot wide goalposts at the Pro Bowl. The percentage of the field goals made was reduced from kickers who are normally "automatic".
Rule 4: Review helmet-to-helmet calls. Where it is found: NCAA
Like pass interference, the helmet-to-helmet calls can impact a game if they are mistakenly called. I understand that in live action, it can be difficult for officials to tell whether or not a player hit another one with his helmet or not. The referees are to rule on the side of safety in this case. There was a dispute on whether (I think it was) Ahmed Brooks of the San Francisco 49ers hit Seattle Seahawks quarterback, Russell Wilson, with his helmet. The referees called the penalty, and it cost the 49ers 15 yards, and Seattle eventually scored on that drive. Later in the week, the NFL reviewed it, and ruled that it should not have been a penalty on the 49ers. If I was King of Sports, those plays would be automatically reviewed like it is in the NCAA. Of course, the reason why it is reviewed in the NCAA is because those plays are grounds for ejection if the player was considered to be "targeting", and no one wants to see a player ejected for making a hard, legal hit. Those plays should be reviewed, because they can impact a game for one team if the call was ruled to be incorrect.
Thursday, April 23, 2015
Continuation of If I Was King of Sports #3-209 Basketball Tournament
This is what the 2015 bracket would look like of my 209 tournament. The seeding procedure can be found in the original blog.
Pod A (@ Sierra-Manteca)
(8) Gregori-Modesto (MMC) vs. (1) Sierra-Manteca (VOL)
(5) Linden (MLL) vs. (4) Ceres (WAC)
(6) Atwater (CCC) vs. Millennium-Tracy (CCAA)
(7) Lincoln-Stockton (TCAL) vs. Mariposa (SL)
Pod B (@ Modesto Christian)
(8) Denair-SL vs. (1) Modesto Christian (MMC)
(5) Pitman-Turlock (CCC) vs. (4) Central Catholic-Modesto (VOL)
(6) Escalon-TVL vs. (3) Patterson (WAC)
(7) West-Tracy vs. (2) Bear Creek-Stockton (SJAA)
Pod C (@ Brookside Christian-Stockton)
(8) McNair-Stockton (SJAA) vs. (1) Brookside Christian-Stockton (CCAA)
(5) Delhi (SL) vs. (4) Summerville-Tuolumne City (MLL)
(6) El Capitan-Merced (WAC) vs. (3) Manteca (VOL)
(7) Hughes Academy-Stockton (MVL) vs. (2) Beyer-Modesto (MMC)
Pod D (@ Liberty Ranch-Galt)
(8) Oakdale (VOL) vs. (1) Liberty Ranch-Galt (SVC)
(5) Stockton Christian (MVL) vs. (4) Argonaut-Jackson (MLL)
(6) Pacheco-Los Banos (WAC) vs. (3) Tracy (TCAL)
(7) Riverbank (TVL) vs. (2) Turlock (CCC)
Pod E (@ Jim Elliot Christian-Lodi)
(8) Modesto (MMC) vs. (1) Jim Elliot Christian-Lodi (CCAA)
(5) Tokay-Lodi (TCAL) vs. (4) Hughson (TVL)
(6) Kimball-Tracy (VOL) vs. (3) Lodi Academy (MVL)
(7) Le Grand (SL) vs. (2) Chavez-Stockton (SJAA)
Pod F (@ Weston Ranch-Stockton)
(8) Gustine (SL) vs. (1) Weston Ranch-Stockton (VOL)
(5) Big Valley-Modesto (CCAA) vs. (4) Ripon (TVL)
(6) Davis-Modesto (MMC) vs. (3) Sonora (MLL)
(7) Los Banos (WAC) vs. (2) Delta Charter-Tracy (MVL)
Pod G (@ Central Valley-Ceres)
(8) Edison-Stockton (SJAA) vs. (1) Central Valley-Ceres (WAC)
(5) Bret Harte-Angels Camp (MLL) vs. (4) Enochs-Modesto (MMC)
(6) Hilmar (TVL) vs. (3) Merced (CCC)
(7) Turlock Christian (CCAA) vs. St. Mary's-Stockton (TCAL)
Pod H (@ Calaveras-San Andreas)
(8) Livingston (WAC) vs. (1) Calaveras-San Andreas (MLL)
(5) Golden Valley-Merced (CCC) vs. (4) Lodi (TCAL)
(6) Johansen-Modesto (MMC) vs. (3) Central Valley Christian Academy-Ceres (IND)
(7) Sierra Ridge/Rite of Passage-San Andreas (CCAA) vs. (2) Ripon Chirstian (TVL)
Like last year, if I was King of Sports, pod champions would meet at the Stockton Arena,
Runners up would meet at the University of Pacific in Stockton
3rd place- Stanislaus State in Turlock
4th place- UC-Merced
5th place- Delta College (Stockton)
6th place- Modesto Junior College
7th place- Merced College
8th place- Columbia College (Sonora)
Non-advancing pods
These would be optional if the teams wanted an opportunity to play more basketball
Pod I (@ Downey-Modesto)
(8) Galt (SVC) vs. (1) Downey-Modesto (MMC)
(5) Lathrop (VOL) vs. (4) Stagg-Stockton (SJAA)
(6) Benjamin Holt Academy-Stockton (MVL) vs. (3) Excel Academy-Stockton (CCAA)
(7) Waterford (SL) vs. (2) Amador-Sutter Creek (MLL)
Pod J (@ Orestimba-Newman)
(8) Tioga-Groveland (MVL) @ (1) Orestimba-Newman (SL)
(5) Franklin-Stockton (SJAA) vs. (4) Humphreys-Stockton (MVL)
(6) Dos Palos (WSL) vs. (3) Stone Ridge Christian-Merced (CCAA)
(7) Buhach Colony-Atwater (CCC) vs. (2) East Union-Manteca (VOL)
Pod A (@ Sierra-Manteca)
(8) Gregori-Modesto (MMC) vs. (1) Sierra-Manteca (VOL)
(5) Linden (MLL) vs. (4) Ceres (WAC)
(6) Atwater (CCC) vs. Millennium-Tracy (CCAA)
(7) Lincoln-Stockton (TCAL) vs. Mariposa (SL)
Pod B (@ Modesto Christian)
(8) Denair-SL vs. (1) Modesto Christian (MMC)
(5) Pitman-Turlock (CCC) vs. (4) Central Catholic-Modesto (VOL)
(6) Escalon-TVL vs. (3) Patterson (WAC)
(7) West-Tracy vs. (2) Bear Creek-Stockton (SJAA)
Pod C (@ Brookside Christian-Stockton)
(8) McNair-Stockton (SJAA) vs. (1) Brookside Christian-Stockton (CCAA)
(5) Delhi (SL) vs. (4) Summerville-Tuolumne City (MLL)
(6) El Capitan-Merced (WAC) vs. (3) Manteca (VOL)
(7) Hughes Academy-Stockton (MVL) vs. (2) Beyer-Modesto (MMC)
Pod D (@ Liberty Ranch-Galt)
(8) Oakdale (VOL) vs. (1) Liberty Ranch-Galt (SVC)
(5) Stockton Christian (MVL) vs. (4) Argonaut-Jackson (MLL)
(6) Pacheco-Los Banos (WAC) vs. (3) Tracy (TCAL)
(7) Riverbank (TVL) vs. (2) Turlock (CCC)
Pod E (@ Jim Elliot Christian-Lodi)
(8) Modesto (MMC) vs. (1) Jim Elliot Christian-Lodi (CCAA)
(5) Tokay-Lodi (TCAL) vs. (4) Hughson (TVL)
(6) Kimball-Tracy (VOL) vs. (3) Lodi Academy (MVL)
(7) Le Grand (SL) vs. (2) Chavez-Stockton (SJAA)
Pod F (@ Weston Ranch-Stockton)
(8) Gustine (SL) vs. (1) Weston Ranch-Stockton (VOL)
(5) Big Valley-Modesto (CCAA) vs. (4) Ripon (TVL)
(6) Davis-Modesto (MMC) vs. (3) Sonora (MLL)
(7) Los Banos (WAC) vs. (2) Delta Charter-Tracy (MVL)
Pod G (@ Central Valley-Ceres)
(8) Edison-Stockton (SJAA) vs. (1) Central Valley-Ceres (WAC)
(5) Bret Harte-Angels Camp (MLL) vs. (4) Enochs-Modesto (MMC)
(6) Hilmar (TVL) vs. (3) Merced (CCC)
(7) Turlock Christian (CCAA) vs. St. Mary's-Stockton (TCAL)
Pod H (@ Calaveras-San Andreas)
(8) Livingston (WAC) vs. (1) Calaveras-San Andreas (MLL)
(5) Golden Valley-Merced (CCC) vs. (4) Lodi (TCAL)
(6) Johansen-Modesto (MMC) vs. (3) Central Valley Christian Academy-Ceres (IND)
(7) Sierra Ridge/Rite of Passage-San Andreas (CCAA) vs. (2) Ripon Chirstian (TVL)
Like last year, if I was King of Sports, pod champions would meet at the Stockton Arena,
Runners up would meet at the University of Pacific in Stockton
3rd place- Stanislaus State in Turlock
4th place- UC-Merced
5th place- Delta College (Stockton)
6th place- Modesto Junior College
7th place- Merced College
8th place- Columbia College (Sonora)
Non-advancing pods
These would be optional if the teams wanted an opportunity to play more basketball
Pod I (@ Downey-Modesto)
(8) Galt (SVC) vs. (1) Downey-Modesto (MMC)
(5) Lathrop (VOL) vs. (4) Stagg-Stockton (SJAA)
(6) Benjamin Holt Academy-Stockton (MVL) vs. (3) Excel Academy-Stockton (CCAA)
(7) Waterford (SL) vs. (2) Amador-Sutter Creek (MLL)
Pod J (@ Orestimba-Newman)
(8) Tioga-Groveland (MVL) @ (1) Orestimba-Newman (SL)
(5) Franklin-Stockton (SJAA) vs. (4) Humphreys-Stockton (MVL)
(6) Dos Palos (WSL) vs. (3) Stone Ridge Christian-Merced (CCAA)
(7) Buhach Colony-Atwater (CCC) vs. (2) East Union-Manteca (VOL)
Saturday, January 31, 2015
New CIF Football Format
1/31/15
Yesterday, the CIF approved a new 13-division format for the state football championship. This ensures that every 11-man section champion will get at least a regional bowl game. Also, the divisions will be based on competitive equality and not by enrollment. One division will have a play-in game for the Northern California regional bowl. At this point, I do not know how they will work that out, or how they will decide "competitive equality". That did not stop me from wondering what the regional bowl games would look like if the CIF did that this year. This blog will provide one possibility. Based solely on calpreps.com ratings, here is what the regional games would look like.
First what we need to know: The Northern California region is the Central Coast, North Coast, Northern, Oakland, Sac-Joaquin, and San Francisco sections. The Southern California region is the Los Angeles, San Diego, and Southern sections. Starting next year, the Central Section will be split between North and South. The Central Section Divisions I, III, and V champions will be in the North. The Divisions II, IV, and VI champions will remain in the South.
Next what we must assume: For this blog, we are going to assume that all the higher-rated teams will choose to host, and not have the game at a neutral site, or have the opponents host.
Division Open Large
North: Folsom @ De La Salle (Concord)
South: Centennial (Corona)
Note: Normally, the lower-division would have the play-in game. However, in this, I can see the top division having the play-in game. I am sure the CIF would want to give the top team in the South a bye week.
Division 1A
North: Campolindo (Moraga) @ Grant (Sacramento)
South: Mission Viejo @ Oceanside
Division 1AA
North: Clayton Valley (Concord) @ Edison (Fresno)
South: El Capitan (Lakeside) @ Redlands East Valley (Redlands)
Division 2A
North: Sacred Heart Prep (Atherton) @ Enterprise (Redding)
South: Paso Robles @ Trabuco Hills (Mission Viejo)
Division 2AA
North: Sutter @ Oakdale
South: Crescenta Valley (La Crescenta) @ Ridgeview (Bakersfield)
Division 3A
North: Aptos @ Hanford
South: St. Augustine (San Diego) @ Narbonne (Los Angeles-Harbor City)
Division 3AA
North: Central Catholic (Modesto) @ St. Francis (Mountain View)
South: Palos Verdes (Palos Verdes Estates) @ Colony (Ontario)
Division 4A
North: McClymonds (Oakland) @ San Benito (Hollister)
South: Liberty (Madera) @ Palm Springs
Division 4AA
North: Salesian (Richmond) @ Justin-Siena (Napa)
South: Pomona @ Christian (El Cajon)
Division 5A
North: Terra Nova (Pacifica) @ Capital Christian (Sacramento)
South: Nipomo @ Bishop's (La Jolla)
Division 5AA
North: Winters @ Bear River (Grass Valley)
South: St. Margaret's (San Juan Capistrano) @ Hamilton (Los Angeles)
Division 6A
North: Maxwell @ Corcoran
South: Kennedy (Delano) @ Garden Grove
Division: 6AA
North: Stone Ridge Christian (Merced) @ Mission (San Francisco)
South: La Jolla Country Day (La Jolla) @ Los Angeles
Note: One source I read says all divisions will be based on "competitive equality". Another source says only two divisions will be based on "competitive equality" and the rest will be on enrollment. I went with the first source for my model. If it turns out that the second one is correct, then Mission (San Francisco) and Los Angeles would be placed in higher divisions.
Sources: Modesto Bee, sfgate blog, calpreps.com,
Yesterday, the CIF approved a new 13-division format for the state football championship. This ensures that every 11-man section champion will get at least a regional bowl game. Also, the divisions will be based on competitive equality and not by enrollment. One division will have a play-in game for the Northern California regional bowl. At this point, I do not know how they will work that out, or how they will decide "competitive equality". That did not stop me from wondering what the regional bowl games would look like if the CIF did that this year. This blog will provide one possibility. Based solely on calpreps.com ratings, here is what the regional games would look like.
First what we need to know: The Northern California region is the Central Coast, North Coast, Northern, Oakland, Sac-Joaquin, and San Francisco sections. The Southern California region is the Los Angeles, San Diego, and Southern sections. Starting next year, the Central Section will be split between North and South. The Central Section Divisions I, III, and V champions will be in the North. The Divisions II, IV, and VI champions will remain in the South.
Next what we must assume: For this blog, we are going to assume that all the higher-rated teams will choose to host, and not have the game at a neutral site, or have the opponents host.
Division Open Large
North: Folsom @ De La Salle (Concord)
South: Centennial (Corona)
Note: Normally, the lower-division would have the play-in game. However, in this, I can see the top division having the play-in game. I am sure the CIF would want to give the top team in the South a bye week.
Division 1A
North: Campolindo (Moraga) @ Grant (Sacramento)
South: Mission Viejo @ Oceanside
Division 1AA
North: Clayton Valley (Concord) @ Edison (Fresno)
South: El Capitan (Lakeside) @ Redlands East Valley (Redlands)
Division 2A
North: Sacred Heart Prep (Atherton) @ Enterprise (Redding)
South: Paso Robles @ Trabuco Hills (Mission Viejo)
Division 2AA
North: Sutter @ Oakdale
South: Crescenta Valley (La Crescenta) @ Ridgeview (Bakersfield)
Division 3A
North: Aptos @ Hanford
South: St. Augustine (San Diego) @ Narbonne (Los Angeles-Harbor City)
Division 3AA
North: Central Catholic (Modesto) @ St. Francis (Mountain View)
South: Palos Verdes (Palos Verdes Estates) @ Colony (Ontario)
Division 4A
North: McClymonds (Oakland) @ San Benito (Hollister)
South: Liberty (Madera) @ Palm Springs
Division 4AA
North: Salesian (Richmond) @ Justin-Siena (Napa)
South: Pomona @ Christian (El Cajon)
Division 5A
North: Terra Nova (Pacifica) @ Capital Christian (Sacramento)
South: Nipomo @ Bishop's (La Jolla)
Division 5AA
North: Winters @ Bear River (Grass Valley)
South: St. Margaret's (San Juan Capistrano) @ Hamilton (Los Angeles)
Division 6A
North: Maxwell @ Corcoran
South: Kennedy (Delano) @ Garden Grove
Division: 6AA
North: Stone Ridge Christian (Merced) @ Mission (San Francisco)
South: La Jolla Country Day (La Jolla) @ Los Angeles
Note: One source I read says all divisions will be based on "competitive equality". Another source says only two divisions will be based on "competitive equality" and the rest will be on enrollment. I went with the first source for my model. If it turns out that the second one is correct, then Mission (San Francisco) and Los Angeles would be placed in higher divisions.
Sources: Modesto Bee, sfgate blog, calpreps.com,
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)